10 Christ-Centered Toys for Toddlers This Holiday Season

As an Amazon Associate, I earn a commission on qualifying purchases.

Toddlers may be tiny, but their hearts and minds are wide open to the wonder of God’s love. That’s why Christ-centered toys for toddlers this holiday season are such powerful gifts—they entertain, teach, and introduce Jesus in playful, age-appropriate ways.

Whether you’re a parent, grandparent, godparent, or Sunday school teacher, giving a toy that points a little one toward Christ is one of the most beautiful investments you can make. These gifts don’t just bring smiles on Christmas morning. They plant seeds of faith that will grow for years to come.

From plush Bibles to interactive nativity sets, these 10 toys combine fun and faith to make Jesus the true center of a toddler’s Christmas.

1. My First Bible Storybook (Plush or Board Book Edition)

For toddlers who love story time, a beginner’s Bible filled with vibrant pictures and simplified Scripture is the perfect gift. Board books like “The Beginner’s Bible” or “Jesus Storybook Bible for Toddlers” bring the Word to life with colorful, captivating illustrations.

Choose a softcover plush version or a durable hardback made for tiny hands—either way, it becomes a bedtime favorite and a foundation of truth.

2. Fisher-Price Little People Nativity Set

This classic set is a Christ-centered holiday must-have. With baby Jesus, Mary, Joseph, shepherds, animals, and even an angel that lights up, toddlers can role-play the birth of Jesus in a way they understand.

It’s fun, safe, and turns playtime into a teachable moment about the real reason for Christmas. Place it under the tree or in the nursery—it’s a gift that stays relevant all season long.

3. Jesus Loves Me Singing Stuffed Animal

Plush toys that sing songs like “Jesus Loves Me” bring comfort, calm, and connection. These cuddly companions are ideal for naptime or quiet moments, reminding little ones that they are deeply loved.

Some versions even include Scripture tags or embroidered crosses, adding another layer of meaning to this huggable gift.

4. Wooden Noah’s Ark Playset

A durable, colorful Noah’s Ark made from toddler-safe wood or BPA-free plastic teaches about God’s promises while building fine motor skills.

Look for sets with pairs of animals and chunky character pieces that are easy for small hands to grasp. It’s a great way to bring Bible stories to life while encouraging imaginative play rooted in truth.

5. ABC Scripture Memory Cards for Kids

Start their journey into God’s Word early with flashcards that pair each letter of the alphabet with a Bible verse. A is for “All have sinned…”, B is for “Be kind…”, and so on.

These cards are perfect for interactive learning with parents or older siblings and help toddlers begin hiding God’s Word in their hearts—even before they can read.

6. Jesus Doll or Soft Bible Character Dolls

Soft plush dolls of Jesus, Moses, or Esther are wonderful tools for teaching toddlers about the heroes of the faith. These dolls make abstract stories feel tangible and relatable.

Whether used during playtime or Bible reading, these toys remind little ones that God’s love is real, personal, and always near.

7. Christian-Themed Wooden Puzzles

Puzzles that feature Bible stories—like Jonah and the Whale, Noah’s Ark, or the birth of Christ—are perfect for developing hand-eye coordination while reinforcing faith themes.

Choose puzzles with bright colors, chunky pieces, and simple imagery that sparks curiosity and conversation.

8. Faith-Based Musical Instruments

From tambourines printed with “Make a joyful noise” to baby-safe maracas with crosses, musical toys allow toddlers to worship God with movement and joy.

They’re perfect for Christmas morning dance parties or Sunday sing-alongs in the living room. Plus, they help children associate praise with fun and freedom.

9. Lift-the-Flap Bible Books

Curious toddlers love interactive books, and lift-the-flap versions of popular Bible stories are a hit. Books like “Lift the Flap Bible” or “Peek-a-Boo Jesus” help kids engage with the story of Christ through surprises and discovery.

These books are not only educational but create sweet bonding time during read-alouds.

10. "First 100: First 100 Bible Words Padded" Book

Language development meets faith foundation in this padded board book featuring 100 simple Bible words like "God," "Jesus," "love," and "prayer," often paired with bright pictures. 

This type of book is ideal for toddlers learning their first words—and it gently introduces them to the core vocabulary and concepts of faith from the very beginning.

Make This Season Holy: Shop Christ-Centered Toys for Toddlers Today

This year, let your gift-giving reflect what matters most. Christ-centered toys for toddlers offer more than fun—they offer foundations. They plant faith early, speak life in little hearts, and remind even the youngest ones of the joy and truth of Jesus.

Whether it’s a plush Jesus doll, a singing Bible verse toy, or a nativity set they can touch and play with, these gifts keep Christ front and center—not just on Christmas morning, but every day after.

So as you wrap presents and fill stockings, remember: the most meaningful gifts don’t just entertain—they point tiny hearts toward eternity.

Reader’s Favorite:

• Top 10 Christian Christmas Gifts for Devout Moms Under $50

• 10 Faith-Filled Stocking Stuffers for Christian Teens

• 10 Christian Ornaments for Couple's First Christmas

• 10 Bible Verse Wall Art Ideas for Christian Grandparents

• 10 Christmas Prayer Journals for Christian Men's Faith

• 10 Inspirational Books to Encourage Pastors This Christmas

• Top 10 Christian Jewelry Gifts for Women in 2025