Must-Have Holiday Gifts for Pets Under $25

As an Amazon Associate, I earn a commission on qualifying purchases.

You don’t need to spend a fortune to show your furry friend some holiday love. In fact, some of the best gifts come in small, budget-friendly packages. This curated guide of must-have holiday gifts for pets under $25 proves that thoughtful, fun, and festive presents can still make tails wag and whiskers twitch—without breaking the bank.

Whether you're shopping for a playful pup, a curious kitty, or a small critter with a big personality, these under-$25 gifts offer joy, bonding, and plenty of paw-sitive vibes this holiday season.

1. Plush Squeaky Toys in Holiday Shapes

Every pup loves a squeaky toy—and holiday-themed ones take the cuteness up a notch. Think gingerbread men, reindeer, or snowflake-shaped plushies. These soft toys are perfect for chewing, snuggling, or starring in your pet's next Christmas photo shoot.

They bring a whole lot of festive fun and fit easily into a stocking, making them the ideal low-cost surprise.

2. Catnip-Infused Kicker Toys

Looking to treat a feisty feline? Catnip kicker toys are a hit. Designed to be hugged and bunny-kicked, these toys are infused with irresistible catnip and often come wrapped in holiday-themed fabric.

For under $25, you’re giving the gift of stimulation, exercise, and joy—all rolled into one.

3. Festive Bandanas and Bowties

A stylish accessory is one of the easiest ways to include your pet in the holiday festivities. Seasonal bandanas, bowties, or collars with red-and-green patterns or tiny snowflakes instantly upgrade your pet’s look.

It’s an affordable way to make your pet feel dapper at family gatherings or stand out in the annual Christmas card.

4. Holiday Meowijuana Pack

Pet-safe holiday treat samplers are always a hit. Whether it’s peanut butter dog biscuits shaped like stockings or salmon-flavored cat nibbles shaped like stars, these snacks are fun to unwrap and even more fun to munch.

Many come in festive packaging and offer a variety of flavors—perfect for pets with curious taste buds.

5. Crinkle Tunnels for Small Pets

Got a guinea pig, bunny, or ferret? Crinkle tunnels are a cozy and stimulating gift that provides hours of entertainment. Many are collapsible, lightweight, and even lined with fleece for extra comfort.

They’re the kind of under-$25 find that turns any corner of your home into a play zone.

6. Interactive Puzzle Toys

Mental stimulation matters just as much as physical play. Puzzle toys that hide treats inside encourage pets to problem-solve, focus, and stay engaged. These toys are ideal for dogs and cats alike and are often made with durable materials that last well beyond the holidays.

They’re budget-friendly brain boosters your pet will go back to again and again.

7. Pet-Safe Holiday Chew Bones

If you’re gifting a heavy chewer, festive dental bones or holiday-flavored chews are the way to go. Designed to clean teeth and freshen breath while satisfying the urge to gnaw, these treats are as practical as they are delicious.

Plus, they often come in candy cane or snowman shapes—adding just the right amount of holiday flair.

8. Cozy Fleece Blankets

Soft, machine-washable fleece blankets are a warm, comforting gift for pets of all sizes. Drape them in a crate, on the couch, or in a car seat—these blankets help pets feel safe, loved, and comfy wherever they go.

And at under $25, you can even grab an extra one to stash in your travel bag or give to a pet parent friend.

9. LED Safety Collars for Winter Walks

With shorter daylight hours during the holiday season, visibility is key. LED collars or clip-on lights make evening walks safer and more stylish. Many are waterproof, rechargeable, and come in fun colors that add a festive glow to your pet’s daily stroll.

It’s a practical and thoughtful gift that keeps safety top of mind—all without spending big.

10. Refillable Catnip Toys or Treat Balls

Some of the best gifts keep giving long after the holidays are over. Refillable catnip toys or treat-dispensing balls let owners refresh the fun again and again. They’re perfect for indoor playtime during chilly winter days and help reduce boredom or anxiety.

It’s enrichment wrapped in festive fun—all for a very wallet-friendly price.

Shop Must-Have Holiday Gifts for Pets Under $25

Finding the perfect gift for your furry family member doesn’t mean overspending. These must-have holiday gifts for pets under $25 prove that love, joy, and festive fun can all be found in thoughtful, affordable ways.

Whether you're stuffing a stocking, wrapping a small surprise, or just looking for something to show your appreciation for your loyal companion, these picks bring big smiles—on any budget.

Because at the end of the day, it’s not about the price tag. It’s about wagging tails, happy zoomies, and purring cuddles under the tree.

Reader’s Favorite:

• Best Christmas Gifts for Pet Lovers in 2025

• Cute Holiday Gifts Every Pet Owner Will Adore

• Christmas Gift Ideas for Pets and Their Humans