The O’Jays’ Most Underrated Songs: Eddie Levert’s Hidden Gems You Need to Hear

The best underrated O’Jays songs reveal a depth of artistry and emotional storytelling that often goes unnoticed beneath the band’s chart-topping hits. While classics like Love Train and For the Love of Money have cemented The O’Jays’ legacy in soul music, their discography is filled with overlooked gems that showcase Eddie Levert’s unmatched vocal prowess and the band’s timeless influence on R&B. These hidden treasures offer a deeper glimpse into the evolution of soul, proving that The O’Jays’ impact extends far beyond their greatest hits.

The O’Jays: More Than Just Hitmakers

The O’Jays, formed in the late 1950s, rose to fame under the guidance of Philadelphia International Records, spearheaded by legendary producers Kenny Gamble and Leon Huff. Their smooth harmonies and socially conscious lyrics became the gold standard for R&B and soul. Yet, while their most famous tracks continue to be celebrated, many lesser-known songs deserve recognition for their emotional depth, innovative production, and lasting influence.

Eddie Levert, the group’s lead singer, has long been recognized for his powerful, heartfelt delivery. His ability to translate raw emotion into music is a defining feature of The O’Jays’ sound. This article explores some of their most overlooked masterpieces—songs that capture the essence of soul but never quite received mainstream attention.

1. “This Time Baby” (1978)

Overshadowed by more prominent hits from the So Full of Love album, This Time Baby is an exhilarating blend of funk and disco that showcases The O’Jays’ versatility. The track’s infectious groove, layered instrumentation, and Eddie Levert’s commanding vocals make it a dancefloor classic that deserved more radio play. Interestingly, this song later became a club hit when Jackie Moore covered it in 1979, proving its enduring appeal.

2. “Let Me Make Love to You” (1975)

From their iconic Family Reunion album, this sensual ballad is a prime example of Eddie Levert’s ability to convey deep longing and passion. With lush orchestration and soul-stirring harmonies, Let Me Make Love to You highlights The O’Jays’ softer, more intimate side. Despite its emotional potency, it remains one of their more overlooked romantic ballads.

3. “Your Body’s Here with Me (But Your Mind’s on the Other Side of Town)” (1982)

One of the most emotionally charged songs in The O’Jays’ catalog, this track delves into themes of heartbreak and emotional detachment. Levert’s vocals are particularly gripping, painting a vivid picture of love slipping away. The song’s melancholic instrumentation perfectly complements its sorrowful narrative, making it a standout track from When Will I See You Again.

4. “You and Me” (1975)

Another overlooked masterpiece from Family Reunion, You and Me is a slow-burning love song that encapsulates The O’Jays’ signature blend of heartfelt storytelling and impeccable harmonies. The song’s introspective lyrics and smooth melody make it one of their most underrated romantic tracks, offering a perfect showcase for Eddie Levert’s impassioned delivery.

5. “Hurry Up and Come Back” (1987)

By the late 1980s, The O’Jays had evolved their sound to adapt to contemporary R&B trends. Hurry Up and Come Back, from the album Let Me Touch You, features a polished production style that blends classic soul with modern R&B elements. The song’s urgency and heartfelt plea for a lost love resonate deeply, proving The O’Jays’ ability to remain relevant across decades.

6. “How Time Flies” (1976)

This poignant ballad from Message in the Music explores themes of nostalgia and the passage of time. The track’s rich instrumentation and reflective lyrics make it one of The O’Jays’ most moving compositions. Levert’s vocals shine with sincerity, making How Time Flies a hidden gem that deserves more recognition among soul aficionados.

7. “Cry Together” (1978)

A song that perfectly encapsulates The O’Jays’ ability to turn raw emotion into music, Cry Together remains one of their most compelling ballads. The blend of sorrowful lyrics and soulful harmonies makes it a timeless track that resonates with anyone who has experienced the ups and downs of love.

Why These Songs Matter

While The O’Jays are celebrated for their chart-topping hits, their lesser-known songs provide a richer understanding of their artistry. These hidden gems reveal their ability to blend raw emotion with masterful storytelling, a testament to Eddie Levert’s vocal brilliance and the group’s unwavering dedication to soul music.

Beyond their music, The O’Jays have shaped the cultural landscape of R&B. Many of their songs carried powerful messages about love, resilience, and social change—elements that still resonate with audiences today. Exploring their underrated catalog allows fans to appreciate their full range of talent, from danceable grooves to heart-wrenching ballads.

Rediscovering The O’Jays’ Legacy

The O’Jays’ deep cuts deserve as much recognition as their greatest hits. Eddie Levert’s voice, filled with passion and authenticity, elevates each track, turning even the most overlooked songs into unforgettable musical experiences. Whether you’re a longtime fan or a newcomer to their music, diving into these hidden gems is a rewarding journey into the heart and soul of one of the greatest R&B groups of all time.

So, if you’re looking to expand your appreciation of soul music, start with these underrated O’Jays songs. You may just find a new favorite that resonates just as powerfully as their biggest hits.

Reader’s Favorites:

• Samuel L. Jackson’s Hollywood Debut: The Untold Story of His First Roles

• How Stevie Wonder’s Music and Advocacy Advanced Disability Rights

• Issa Rae’s Impact on Black Storytelling: Her Rise and Legacy

• Morgan Freeman’s Best Underrated Movies You Need to Watch

• Lessons in Resilience: Oprah Winfrey's Journey to Overcoming Adversity

• The Rise and Fall of Bill Cosby: A Timeline of His Career

• Danny Glover’s Most Underrated Movies You Need to Watch

• 7 Times Al Green’s Music Was Sampled in Hip-Hop and R&B Hits

• Gladys Knight's Most Underrated Songs: A Top 12 Countdown