Top 15 New York Mets Christmas Gifts for Amazin’ Fans

As an Amazon Associate, I earn a commission on qualifying purchases.

New York Mets gifts are the perfect way to hit a home run this holiday season for any Amazin' fan in your life. From Citi Field staples to nostalgic throwbacks, these Christmas gift ideas capture the pride, passion, and blue-and-orange magic of being a Mets fan. Whether you're shopping for a lifelong supporter or a new believer in Queens, this list has you covered with 15 Mets gift ideas sure to deliver major league joy.

1. Mets Can & Bottle Holder Insulator

Keep your drinks cold and your team spirit high. This Mets-themed beverage cooler is perfect for tailgates, watch parties, or backyard BBQs. Whether you're sipping a cold one during the seventh-inning stretch or repping the Amazin’s year-round, this insulated holder is a practical gift for fans who never let their loyalty—or their drink—go warm.

2. Mets Throw Blanket with Retro Logo

Perfect for cold winter nights or cozy game-day vibes, a plush Mets throw featuring the retro skyline logo brings warmth and nostalgia to any fan's space.

3. Mets Dad Hat

Classic, comfortable, and full of team pride. This Mets dad hat is the perfect everyday accessory for fans who like to keep it casual while repping the orange and blue. With its relaxed fit and timeless style, it’s a go-to gift for any supporter—whether they’re catching a game at Citi Field or just showing love for the squad on a Sunday stroll.

4. Mets New Era 59FIFTY Fitted Cap

No true fan’s wardrobe is complete without a classic fitted Mets cap. Look for the timeless blue cap with the orange NY logo—a symbol of New York pride.

5. Mets Holiday Ornament

Add a touch of baseball spirit to your Christmas tree with a Mets ornament featuring caps, balls, and logos in festive colors.

6. Mets Logo Soft Baseballs

Perfect for play or display, these soft Mets logo baseballs are a home run gift for fans of all ages. Great for a casual game of catch, autograph collecting, or adding to a Mets-themed room, they bring a fun and nostalgic vibe. Whether you're gifting a young fan or a longtime supporter, these baseballs let them hold a piece of the Amazin’s legacy right in their hand.

7. New York Mets Double-Sided Garden Flag

Let your Mets pride fly high—literally. This double-sided garden flag is a bold and stylish way to show team spirit right from your front yard. With vibrant colors and logos on both sides, it’s the perfect gift for superfans who want to turn their home into Amazin’s territory, whether it’s game day or the off-season.

8. Mets Dugout Mug

Sip your coffee or hot chocolate from a dugout mug made from a real baseball bat barrel. It’s a unique twist that fans love and a conversation starter for sure.

9. Mets 5-Piece 3D Multi Magnet Set

Stick with the Mets—literally. This 5-piece 3D magnet set adds a fun, dimensional touch to any fridge, locker, or workspace. Featuring bold team graphics and different designs, it’s a great way for fans to bring a little Amazin’ energy into their everyday spaces. A perfect stocking stuffer or small gift for anyone who can’t get enough of Mets baseball.

10. New York Mets Large Pennant

A classic symbol of team pride, this large Mets pennant is a must-have for any true fan’s collection. Perfect for decorating bedrooms, offices, or fan caves, it brings a vintage vibe with a bold, modern twist. Whether it’s hanging on the wall or waving on game day, this pennant is a timeless gift that lets Mets fans show their colors loud and proud.

11. Mets Backpack with Team Logo

Stylish and functional, a Mets backpack is great for school, work, or traveling to games. Bonus points for compartments made to hold gloves or baseballs.

12. Mets Team Logo Baseball Wristbands

Stay cool and rep the Mets at the same time. These team-logo wristbands are a functional and stylish gift for fans who play ball or just want to complete their game-day outfit. Great for costumes, uniforms, or everyday wear, they soak up sweat while showing off that Amazin’ pride. Perfect for kids, athletes, or anyone who wants to wear their loyalty on their sleeve—literally.

13. 21-Piece Baseball Sticker Pack

Customize your gear with a splash of baseball flair. This 21-piece sticker set is perfect for decorating water bottles, laptops, bikes, and more with bold, sporty designs. Sized just right at 2–2.5 inches, they’re durable, fun, and make great stocking stuffers or add-ons for Mets fans who love to personalize everything with a touch of the game they love.

14. New York Mets 2-Color Can Cooler

Double the color, double the team pride. This Mets 2-color can cooler keeps your drink cold while showing off bold team spirit from every angle. Whether you're tailgating, grilling, or just relaxing during the game, it’s the perfect game-day companion. A practical and spirited gift for Mets fans who want to keep their beverages chilled and their loyalty loud.

15. Mets Chrome Metal License Plate Frame

Turn every drive into a victory lap with this sleek Mets chrome license plate frame. Featuring bold team lettering and a shiny metal finish, it’s a stylish way to rep the Amazin’s on the road. Durable and eye-catching, it’s a great gift for diehard fans who want to show their team pride wherever they go—from the parking lot to the highway.

Where to Buy the Best New York Mets Gifts Online

From memorabilia to gear with personality, these New York Mets Christmas gifts deliver holiday cheer with every pitch. Each item honors the legacy and future of the Mets while helping fans celebrate their love for the team in style. Whether you're wrapping up a jersey, an ornament, or a game-ready accessory, one thing is clear: Amazin' fans deserve Amazin' gifts.

Reader’s Favorites:

• Must-Have Minnesota Twins Christmas Gifts for North Star State Fans

• Top Oakland Athletics Christmas Gift Picks for Green & Gold Fans

• Out-of-This-World Houston Astros Christmas Gifts for Every Fan

• Royal-Worthy Christmas Gifts for Kansas City Royals Fans

• Perfect Philadelphia Phillies Christmas Gifts 2025

• Heaven-Sent Los Angeles Angels Christmas Gifts for Baseball Believers

• Great Washington Nationals Christmas Gift Ideas for D.C. Baseball Lovers

• Best Atlanta Braves Christmas Gifts to Knock It Out of the Park