Stocking Stuffers for Pets You Can’t Miss

As an Amazon Associate, I earn a commission on qualifying purchases.

Christmas morning isn’t just for the kids anymore—your furry friends deserve a little magic, too. If you’re looking to make tails wag and whiskers twitch with joy, these stocking stuffers for pets you can’t miss are small in size but big in holiday cheer.

From tasty treats to tiny toys, every pick on this list is budget-friendly, delightfully festive, and guaranteed to make your pet feel like they’re on Santa’s “Nice” list. Whether you're stuffing a stocking for a dog, cat, rabbit, or any cuddly companion, these surprises are sure to bring joy to your home this holiday season.

1. Holiday-Themed Chew Toys

Mini reindeer, candy canes, and snowmen—holiday chew toys bring festive fun in a size perfect for stockings. These small squeakers and plushies make a great surprise for dogs who love to nibble, toss, or cuddle their toys.

Soft and jingly with seasonal flair, they’re the perfect mix of playful and adorable.

2. Catnip Candy Canes

For felines who love a good frenzy, catnip-infused toys shaped like candy canes or Christmas trees are irresistible. Just toss one in their stocking and watch the rolling, pouncing, and playful chaos unfold.

They’re small, affordable, and always a hit with the kitty crowd.

3. Pet-Safe Holiday Treat Bags

Tuck in a little indulgence with bite-sized holiday treats made specifically for pets. Whether it’s gingerbread-shaped dog biscuits or turkey-flavored cat snacks, these treats are a delicious way to include your furry friend in the Christmas feast.

Look for all-natural options in festive packaging to make it extra special.

4. Jingle Bell Collars

Add some festive flair to your pet’s look with a jingle bell collar or charm. These tiny accessories bring a little musical magic to every step your pet takes and make for great stocking stuffers.

Just be sure they’re lightweight and safe—especially for cats who need breakaway designs.

5. Pet Paw Balm Tins

Winter weather can be tough on paws. A tin of nourishing paw balm helps soothe and protect dry or cracked pads, especially for pups who love long walks in the snow.

It’s a thoughtful, practical gift that says, “I care about your comfort,” and it fits perfectly into a stocking or gift basket.

6. Holiday Bandanas or Bowties

Festive fashion never fails. A cute bandana in a holiday print instantly upgrades your pet’s seasonal style. They’re inexpensive, adorable, and ready for those holiday photoshoots.

Plus, they fold up neatly—ideal for slipping into a stocking without adding bulk.

7. Mini Lick Mats or Slow Feeders

Great for anxious eaters or high-energy pups, small lick mats or slow feeders promote calm, mindful snacking. Add a smear of peanut butter or a soft treat, and you've got an instant activity that entertains and soothes.

Perfectly sized and perfect for curious critters.

8. Squeaky Balls and Teasers

Simple. Fun. Always effective. Dogs love squeaky balls, and cats adore wand teasers. These classic toys come in holiday colors or seasonal shapes and offer hours of interactive play—all from a stocking-sized surprise.

They’re the kind of gift that keeps on giving, even after the wrapping paper’s gone.

9. Treat Dispensers and Puzzle Toys

These mini enrichment toys are a clever way to combine playtime with snack time. Look for small puzzle feeders that challenge your pet to work for their reward—a great way to keep their mind sharp during those long winter days indoors.

Smart, fun, and totally stuffable.

10. Personalized Pet ID Tags

It’s the small things that matter—and a customized ID tag with your pet’s name or a fun message (“I’m a gift, unwrap with love!”) adds both function and charm. They’re lightweight, durable, and easy to slip into a stocking.

Personalized gifts always go the extra mile, and your pet’s wardrobe will thank you.

Shop Stocking Stuffers for Pets You Can’t Miss

The best gifts aren’t always the biggest. These stocking stuffers for pets you can’t miss pack holiday magic into bite-sized packages, bringing comfort, excitement, and connection to your celebrations.

Whether you’re shopping last-minute or building a carefully curated stocking for your beloved pet, each item on this list is proof that joy can come in the smallest surprises. So grab your stocking, stuff it with love, and get ready for paws-itively adorable reactions come Christmas morning.

Reader’s Favorite:

• Best Christmas Gifts for Pet Lovers in 2025

• Cute Holiday Gifts Every Pet Owner Will Adore

• Christmas Gift Ideas for Pets and Their Humans

• Must-Have Holiday Gifts for Pets Under $25

• Last-Minute Christmas Gifts for Your Furry Friends